Alright. You asked why we might not do this, and quite honestly, this sounds fabulous. Buuuuuuuut. I have an aversion to people dying of dysentery (I play far too many Oregon Trail-related games) and I- honestly, I'm rather terrible at ambient conversation (which would probably happen during a siege). Also, I like to play the one manipulating the war and giving out titles, not the one actually fighting. HOWEVER!! I respect you a lot for throwing this idea out there, and for even doing something like this, because a lot of people wouldn't. So I thank you. This would be something I would love to read as a story, and it seems very well formatted. There you have my two cents on the matter. Basically, a ton of personal pref, and not issues with the RP.
[@Kassarock]