[quote=@Mystery Bard]
Plus I also have noted how many passed this by before I officially killed it, sooo...
[/quote]

Crappy metric. It can take days for legitimate attention to be gained, regardless of the quality of the check.

It wasn't my cup of tea, too much assassin stuff (and in my experience, too many shitty metagaming/godmodding assassins that I remember), but it was hardly something to immediately dump. That's a common, and usually fatal mistake on the guild. No patience, no roleplay.