[quote=@Doc Doctor] [@Alexei] You're repeating yourself. If I was the one being vague, then why am I supplying more information? You aren't making any sense. It's called 'Realistic Melee' for a reason. We use facts, references, and stats to define what a character can and cannot do. We don't leave it up to discretion, that's just asking for no limits fallacies. There's nothing competitive about leaving physical stats in a RM fight at the door. Here's the thing. You arrived here three days ago with the competitor, you're very clearly her friend, and you're stating that "There's no such thing as bias" to try and convince me that you should judge this fight. Everything you say is a contradiction, I can scarcely fathom it. Okay. Now, taking that into account, look at your friend's CS. [b][color=ed1c24]NO mentioned physical abilities, outside of simply stating that she's 'fast and agile'.[/color][/b] How much bearing does that have in realistic terms when your character is 6'9" and 228 pounds? Not gonna go there. This is RM, but I won't try to dictate how she should write her own profile. That's why I didn't nag her to specify reach and lifting strength. Benefit of the doubt. It states her height, weight, and build, and that's it. Now, look at my CS. [hider=Captain Kull] [h1][b][i][color=6ecff6][center]Captain Arlgor Kull[/center][/color][/i][/b][/h1] [center][img]https://s28.postimg.org/rgrm85b0t/kulll.png[/img][/center] [b][color=6ecff6]Name: Arlgor Kull[/color][/b] [b][color=6ecff6]Aliases:[/color][/b] Cap'n Kull [b][color=6ecff6]Titles:[/color][/b] Captain of the Crimson Guard [b][color=6ecff6]Age:[/color][/b] 36 [b][color=6ecff6]Gender:[/color][/b] Male [h3][b][i][color=6ecff6][center]Physical Attributes[/center][/color][/i][/b][/h3] [b][color=6ecff6]Build:[/color][/b] 5'7", 172 pounds, heavily muscled [b][color=6ecff6]Eyes:[/color][/b] Dark Brown (close to black), overshadowed by sardonic eyebrows. [b][color=6ecff6]Hair:[/color][/b] A black widow's peak, combed back [b][color=6ecff6]Skin Tone:[/color][/b] Pale [b][color=6ecff6]Dominant Hand:[/color][/b] Left [b][color=6ecff6]Tattoos/Scars/Piercings:[/color][/b] Kull's eyes and mouth have distinct scarring from fistfights, permanent cauliflower ears, several white notches crisscross his chest and arms, presumably left by various bladed weapons. His right forearm is enircled by several deep tissue scars, from when he shoved his hand down a lion's esophagus. [b][color=6ecff6]Day To Day Attire:[/color][/b] A full set of bronze armor (faceless helmet, pauldrons, breastplate, armguards, gauntlets, greaves, the works), a maroon cloak emblazoned with the insignia of a black bull, a sixteen pound double headed greataxe, a twenty-eight inch, pound-and-a-half gladius with chili powder in the scabbard worn on his right flank, a pair of gauche daggers at his waist, a pair strapped to his calves, and one on each flank. Six daggers in all. He's very fond of wearing crimson war paint, in tiger stripes across his face. [img]http://clipart-library.com/images/gie5qGk5T.jpg[/img] [b][color=0072bc]Abilities:[/color][/b] Kull is a physical powerhouse, able to bench 500 and kick through cinderblock like styrofoam with his reinforced greaves. He once killed a lion with asphyxiation by ramming his fist down its throat. He has the reflexes of a professional boxer and the power to match, along with nearly three decades of experience as a manslayer. [/hider] Much, MUCH more detail. If you were even remotely honest, it wouldn't be me you were criticizing for vagueness but your own friend. Of course I know her style is different, she comes from a different site. I'm accommodating that, not trying to inform her she's doing everything wrong. She's not doing things wrong, just differently. Now please let an official judge this thread. Even if they aren't perfect, I should think a bit more subtlety is in order if you're going to try and cheat. I doubt your friend enjoys how you're making them look. [/quote] I have to repeat myself because either you cannot comprehend my points, or are simply ignoring them. Which is fine, that's on you. Videos and huudurr reflexes like a boxer, is vague. Point blank. In fact, the only physical trait you define is his strength, mostly his lifting strength but crunching through a cinderblock is a good enough descriptor. That is where it ends and that is my point. It gives no average speed on which your eyes can register the predicted movement and when the brain sends those signals. You might as well have just put fast and agile which already covers that. So no, you honestly haven't provided much more information. Oh no friendo, I am criticizing you specifically because you are being dishonest you are straight up lying that you have any more detail in terms of reflex/speed than Trist. If it were up to me, I would force both of you to specifically state what that means. After a vigorous wedgieing. In short let me summarize: You're reaction time is about as defined as Trist's speed and agility. The only advantage I would give you is the area of strength. Luckily it is not up to me, but I will make my opininion clear. You are shenanigans. I will leave it at that.