What if we changed it to "rate the quote the above person says about you"

Example:

Person 1: "Whatever doesn't kill you only makes you fatter."

Person 2: 4/10
"Sleep is for the dead."

Person 3: 8/10
etc.

And so on and so forth, the quote can come from anywhere, be something you said, or something you just picked off the interwebs. 

I'll go first, ready?

"Don't worry about it, most really famous people didn't become famous till after they were dead anyway."