[@Mara]

[quote]It was a failed experiment that Mahz stuck at the top of the forum[/quote]

That's a pretty harsh phrasing. Define failed? I saw RPG didn't have a PW. Some had been tried, but as far as staff seemed concerned nobody wanted one. EH not only has a following of people who enjoy the worlds therein, but enjoy the game they're playing. 

And is the only reason anyone on Guild even began talking about any kind of PW, and is kind of the reason you have this one you seem happy to have on the way. 

 [quote]— at the request of the EH mods —[/quote]

Incorrect. I'm not sure where you're getting your information from, but my request from Mahz was a subforum inside of Nation RP, or Advanced. A subforum within a subforum, so as to not be something extra on people's homepage. 

 [quote]in order to give it more exposure and help it gain popularity,[/quote]

That may be why Mahz chose to put it where he did on the board. I never asked, his site he can do what he wants. < Shrug. > 

[quote] but that idea didn't really work, did it?[/quote] 

I don't know, there's quite a few dedicated players in EH - with more than a handful of them only on Guild to play in the EH. So...did it?

[@Life In Stasis]

[quote]I've avoided Expanding Horizons because it became such a hodgepodge mess.[/quote]
???

 [quote]The characters can be literally anything. A demonic dragon, a literal god, a talking hat. It was absurd. Absolute chaos.[/quote] 

Because everything in the universe would all be the same general archetype of creature? If we encounter aliens, they'll look just like us, and be just like us? 

It's an entire universe, and you're going to have a hodgepodge mess of different species and sentient things out there. To say you avoided it because it exists in such a way as to be OPEN AND WELCOMING TO EVERY TYPE OF PLAYER THAT COULD PLAY THE GAME is kind of elitist, buddy.