[quote=@Satoshi Kyou] Jasmine, I only have one problem with her however, This is a huge problem I have with just her, How did she get to rank 4 at the start of the year (which hasn't taken place yet because that's where we start). [/quote] That's on me for misunderstanding the setting. I thought we were partway through the third year already and that the third year rankings were based entirely on your performance in your third year; as in, third year wipes the slate clean and you all start from scratch. I'll make the change you suggested and have her transfer in towards the end of the second year. [quote=@Satoshi Kyou] Touma, There aren't a lot of things that are wrong with him, heck there is NOTHING wrong him at all and he seems to be a great character but... you did say he is the tallest student from all Water dorm which restricts what I can do with Water Dorm student NPC's [/quote] 6'0 is pretty damn tall for Japan and I kind of specifically wanted him to be the tallest. I'll reword it to say "one of the tallest" if its an issue, or maybe just bump his height up to be more exceptional? [quote=@Satoshi Kyou] Asahi, I have plenty of issues with him, for one How did he get to this rank if he doesn't challenge often... the academy doesn't just put you at rank 2 based purely on skill. [/quote] I guess I didn't make it clear enough but the thing with Asahi is that he does have a huge number of wins purely from other people challenging him, enough to be considered one of the best duellists despite not throwing out any challenges of his own. I am also under the assumption that there was no Top 5 for first and second years and that was only for your third year, so the first two years would be entirely ELO based. [quote=@Satoshi Kyou] The same problem as Jasmine, The RP takes place at the start of the third year, in other words, she would be using her new deck for the first few times putting her at a lower rank possibly at the same rank Asahi would be if what your sheet says is true [/quote] Again, I misunderstood this part. I'll change it to say she swapped decks sometime in her second year. [quote=@Satoshi Kyou] How did Kanna get rank 1? if Asahi is rank 2 then HOW did Kanna get past Asahi if they never dueled? Did Asahi refuse to duel her? Kanna would have been number 1 if that's the case, but Asahi's reputation would have been known as the guy who let a girl get past him without putting up a fight [/quote] So I think I need the ranking system cleared up at this point, because I seem to have made a lot of misconceptions. My understanding was that the first and second years were ranked based on an ELO system where you gain points from wins and lose them from loses. Under this system it should be possible for Kanna to rise above Asahi without ever facing him, simply by accumulating more points by dueling other people. I then thought that all ranks were eliminated at the start of the third year and you started accumulating points from scratch. This is clearly not the case. So, do the ranks from your second year just carry over then? Whoever is top of the seconds years becomes #1 at the start of your third year? I think my mistake was thinking that there was only a Top 5 for your third year, with the previous two years being purely points based. I'll have to rethink things then, because I really wanted Kanna vs Asahi to be like a dream match that never happened kind of thing but that seems impossible with this system unless I have Kanna beat Asahi to the Top 5 and just always stay ahead of him. ---- [quote=@Ammokkx] The MBP extra could still remove these cards, I don't see why they should stick around: Lightning Chidori Castel Gaia Dragon [/quote] They are all Wind attribute Rank 4 XYZ. I honestly don't have much to work with. [quote=@Ammokkx] Gear Giant X [/quote] Again, there is a limited selection of Rank 4 machines. I'll add in Heavy Armoured Train Ironwolf though, since I only just noticed it and it seems to fit. [quote=@Ammokkx] Ally Of Justice Catastor is an anti-light killbot. Not really a vehicle or anything, just an eradication killbot. [/quote] I can make a level 5 synchro and, again, limited selection. I can replace it with Hi-Speedroid Chanbara since its a wind, machine spaceship thing, but I wanted to avoid dipping into other archetypes. [quote=@Ammokkx] Tornado Dragon... Okay, nevermind, I'm giving you this one. that's clever. [/quote] I don't know what I did or why this is okay but the other wind monsters aren't.