[quote=@Eddie Brock]
<Snipped quote by AndyC>

It's a tossup for sure. It really comes down to whether you prefer your gaslighting to happen in-universe ("No, Peter, you and MJ were never married. In fact, you guys can't even stand each other!") or out ("Sorry, the Spider-Man you thought you were following was just a clone.").
[/quote]

I think the tie-breaker is that 90s Spidey never made this face:

http://imgur.com/gallery/4RjYORd