And, yes. Garfield was a good Peter, and Spidey. 

Holland's also a good Peter, he nails the younger years personality and I hope they continue to nail it as they have Peter mature and enter college years. His Spidey isn't as good, for me at least, but that primarily comes down to the Iron Man-lite storyline. I'm all for the Iron Spider suit, but not only was it too soon, it was distracting from Peter's overall character.