[s]I really shouldn't join something like this... BUT I AM GOING TO ANYWAY![/s] (What's life without a few bad decisions?)

From what I gathered, the first one will not have fantasy. But this in a fantasy setting sounds fun, so I'm up for fantasy.

A few things beforehand:
I'm up for very small amounts of smut, as long as it doesn't get into 18+ territory.

Of the ideas you proposed beforehand, I like the following: Monsters x human and Wizard x magical creature x human. As for BDSM...  well, that's a risky subject, and even if it doesn't go into porno I still feel it's pretty likely to get into 18+ territory very quickly. So maybe stray away from that. I'm not totally opposed to that idea, just... erm... sceptical? That's not the right word.... you get the idea though.

Hope to hear back from you soon.