[quote=@Inkarnate]
The difference is I'm not calling anything objectively good and bad because I know what the word means and since you have no measure and criteria I'm correct in such deliberation that toy are just using it as a catchall.
[/quote]

And I'm not calling anything objectively good either, so maybe you don't know what it means after all.

[@Fabricant451]

I was mentioning a series, if we are talking about games with black protagonists and I say I'd rather play GTA you'd be a special kind of moron to think I'm talking about GTA 1. So on the subject of tactical RPGs if I mention Valkirie Profile then I'm probably taking about the game in the series that's a tactical RPG. High level detective work I know, but you'll get your head around it.

Famitsu also gave Nintendogs a 40/40. Clearly other games have a lot to learn from this masterpiece.

I didn't say highest bidder, I said they put too much stock in presentation and legacy. You make the exact same argument when a Rockstar Game gets a 10/10 on the same big websites you are citing.