[quote=@Superboy]
The lack of retention and lower quality on average might have something to do with how the boards are separated, honestly. I do like the idea of using sub-boards for genres instead of throwing everything into a giant list and letting the users sort it out, [u][b]but I'm also not a huge fan of sticking the AOL-style one liners beside the Tolkien-wannabes, y'know?[/b][/u] With the three sections, as flawed as they are, they at least give you the chance to find people who gravitate more toward your style.
[/quote]
That's when the tagging system comes into play for helping determine that kind of stuff.