[quote=@Sea Man]
I think in oldguild there was a concrete tier list that people generally agreed on. Though oldguild had also its own circle of people. Those people still exist- there even exists a secondary circle that I can see. So if we have one person define strictly what is what, then we have a game. After that, all we'd need is a character sheet template, and everything else can be made up on the fly.
[/quote]

In theory, the old guild's tier list could work. I think, though, that it would need to be expanded to encompass a broader range. If I recall, it was a 1-10 tier system, with 1 being the lowest (normal human level) and 10 being the highest (basically, Omniversal power). But once you hit that 6/7 mark, the differences between one tier and the one above/below it became pretty wide compared to the 1-5 tier range.