I like the idea of combining 4 and 5, especially since you seem to have some ideas for it already xD

[s]So much relationship drama with Penelope and Gavin, and Crow with Rikki/maybe Hazel. I love it[/s]

I feel like if we included the part with Lucy, Crow would come to resent her really fast because she'll be intruding on his alone time with Penelope lol
I think if we include it, we should wait for a bit so Crow and Penelope have at least some time together and possibly figure out another way to meet up more often
Either way, I'm good to add that in later or some other variation of the idea if we think of something better for Lucy ^^

Sorry it's taking me a while to reply. My phone crapped out on me (it stopped charging and died), so I had to get a new one this morning and it took a long time to set up