[@BrokenPromise] Fandoms aren't my niche, so your perspective is different than mine, but I appreciate the examples you gave. Got me thinking that in roleplays based on games or series with special 'traits' that are central to the setting, sheets would have to account for those. So in your case 'talents' and 'afflictions' would be essential information. The secret questionnaire is an interesting idea. I think your willingness to ask just a bit extra of your players shows that you're dedicated to the roleplay and setting. It'd be neat to see GMs adopt a similar model, in which they had more information with which to judge characters, while players learn about each other's characters over time in the narrative.