Yeah I'm thinking they don't even make it past the first break of the first day xD They could attempt to get some time alone then and he could catch them pretty quickly lol 
Then the meeting with the god and her mother could happen on the second day at night so the third day is just them figuring everything out XD What do you think?

I figured lol Penelope's not going to be happy about it either

My original idea was to just have her tell him about it (like learning a piece of information that was only between her and her mom that makes John accept that) but not I'm kinda leaning towards him seeing her too since it'd be pretty emotional for him as well [s]plus a whole family reunion kinda sounds fun lol [/s]
I'm good with that. I'm thinking what happens is that Penelope and Crow sneak out at night to the pond and then Crow could pass out and Penelope could be visited by the god. After the god leaves, her mom would pop up. John could have woken up at some point and tracked them down just in time to see her too. 

At least, that's what I'm thinking so far cx