[@Royaletutor59] That would work as well.  The strongest impression of a person is usually what people remember first so, in Annabeth's case, it's his fighting ability and the fact that he survived.  In the case of someone who arrived later it would probably have more to do with his surviving infection and delirium.  It could also include rumors about him, either from those who saw him hunting enemies through the streets or from those who might be in-the-know about the death of his fiancé and her family.

A key part of any story is the difference in perspective between characters.  I'm hoping to strengthen that a little by encouraging people to draw information from events that their characters did not directly witness but could have heard about, filtered by the opinions of others of course.