Man, this is tough. I played the game through as a good guy revealing an eagle as Arthur's spirit animal at his grave and a second time as a bad guy; killing everyone he came across revealing a dark coyote as his spirit animal. the best part of RDR2 is the story. I secretly hoped Arthur would have an affair with either Sadie Adler or Charlotte, the widow. None of that and Abigail just pisses me off. Poor John Marston saddled with her whiney ass.