[quote=@Zoey White]
[@Lord Wraith] I forgot you were Batman! That's perfect, actually.

How about Victor Zsasz? That serial killer guy who marks a line on himself whenever he kills someone. I was thinking the Bruce Wayne Batman could have defeated him but he got out a while ago and travelled to New York and just recently began killing again.
[/quote]

I'm okay with you using Zsasz, but Bruce hasn't been Batman for over twenty years, so that might make him a little older than you're anticipating unless he was a bit of a young punk when he was first caught. He doesn't even need to be tied to Batman at all if that works better for you.