Sylvia looked at the four tools carefully, and after carefully considering each tool, she answered Andras, "Thank you! That would definitely be helpful! I think the hunting knife would be of great help on my journeys," 

She may not like killing, but she had a feeling that the hunting knife would definitely help if someone hunted for food. She could not only use it for defense, but she could also use the hunting knife to prep meals and sell pelts as Pylia had mentioned before. So in a way, the knife seemed like the wisest choice.