Charlie shrugs" I don't know I was in a cell the whole time just heard the conversation apparently he won't her throat from what I was able to gather 

Jacob looks at Charlie " Charlie how did you escape ?"

Charlie nods" I did forget to tell you that huh? Well everyday I loosened the spikes that held the shackle in the wall and once I pulled them out an enchantment that has stopped me from shape shifting had been lifted so I turned into a fly and flew out. "