Depending on their interest between the supernatural and mythology? Sure they would, She has trouble believing that it's as simple as spooky ghosts and werewolves and other movie garbage, but she does firmly believe that there is something out there, and that humans have been glorifying it and sometimes even worshiping the supernatural as gods for hundreds of years. 

Oh lord, have somebody get her talking about mythology, especially the story of Persephone. She will talk your ear off about it.