[quote=@Cu Chulainn]
<Snipped quote by KoL>
I suppose I did word that wrong. By personal experience, I really mean I've actually written material involving Gilgamesh in the past, rather than had a bad experience with someone else roleplaying him.

That said, knowing exactly what he is capable of in a roleplay (including his personality in mind), I can't in good conscience allow him in a roleplay with multiple people involved having different stories to be told, and different approaches to those stories.

[/quote]

Forgive me, but the GM mentioned that he's looking for characters up to Gilgamesh's power level (not that I'm using him for power explicitly), which naturally includes Gilgamesh himself. You banning overpowered  characters in a roleplay about overpowered characters makes the premise of this story very confusing to say the least.

Otherwise, say I pick Arjuna and still get banned because he too is too powerful (being just a sliver weaker than Gil) and so and so forth until we are down to the level of normal Servants again.

This smells kinda like false advertisement for me.