[quote=@Cu Chulainn]
<Snipped quote by KoL>
I feel like this argument is made in bad taste when talking about Gilgamesh specifically when we are talking about Servants. Most Servants are limited to a certain theme that keeps them balanced with the rest in some way. This compatibility keeps even the strongest Servants around the same balance as weaker Servants since they are limited around a certain theme. Many Servant fights are scored by compatibility, in this case.

Gilgamesh on the other hand is one of those outliers that can easily be abused due to his signature Noble Phantasm breaking that balance by having a Noble Phantasm that essentially breaks the rule of compatibility. Even though Gate of Babylon is stated to not have specific Noble Phantasms within its vault, there's still the fact that it has an answer to essentially everything else, and smarter players can easily play around his restrictions and win a Grail War with ease. In other words, compatibility is essentially thrown right out the door.

This is why Gilgamesh works well in normal written with his personality in mind, but terrible in works where writers aren't cooperating with each other, like in the case of a roleplay. There's also the fact that the main GM mentioned that the power has been scaled down slightly to "Cu-to-Artoria/tier"
 
[/quote]

First, you are judging people's writing before even seeing it. But most important than that, what part of a power level of around Arturia/Cu is considered a level of normally overpowered Servants? They are Top Servants for sure (which is the kind of Servant most people use in any Fate RPs anyway) but that doesn't make them overpowered. In fact, Arturia and Cu are really strong but balanced.

If this is the angle you two are shooting for now, you may as well rewrite the initial pitch of the RP to not give people false hopes.