[quote=@ItMeGritty]
Could you be a little more constructive as to why this is a bad idea? I think it fits what youre going for.
[/quote]

We're not picking cards based on their real life rarity. It's not a good way to balance the actual power of the cards and with re-prints you can probably find most old cards as common anyway.

The setting is basically the one from 5D's; a shithole outside a much nicer city. The kind of cards you'd find in people's trash are the kind of cards we'd be starting off with.