[quote=@Nightrunner]
I have never really tried a tabletop styled PbP. I've been a Dungeon Master in D&D 5e before but I've never really been a player, so it would be a fresh experience for me for many reasons. I would love to play either way and don't want my curiosity to get in the way of everyone having a good time, but I would vote for tabletop style.

EDIT: Since Flagg actually does care, I'll just swap my vote over to regular storytelling.
[/quote]

to be clear, tabletop not a dealbreaker for me, but would strongly vote for story mode.