Or maybe, just maybe, to the absolute horror of the Police, every file that [i]should[/i] have referred to the Leader.. now refers to some completely different person.
Maybe some of those names are the names of people who vanished mysteriously years prior? Maybe they're the names of some people who threw themselves from the Leap of Faith?
Maybe some of them are even the names of the other members of the Occult Club?

Maybe they're the names of the police themselves?

Man, wouldn't that be freaky? Reading up on a file about a missing person's case, only to see [i]your[/i] name?