[quote=thewizardguy]
You know that I'm stubborn and precise enough to go into an example like that and analyze every detail to determine who would win in a fight assuming certain basic principals about the area and other circumstances under which the fight occurs.
[/quote]

fine. then it was a lone madoka before she became a magical girl... which is the only possibility for the fight since she literally became the embodiment of hope and left the physical plane...