[quote=@Moonshadow]
<Snipped quote by Zanavy>

Some will say Aaranya did it, she has a criminal history after all! Or could it have been the creature in a bought of anger that Aaranya was not "proper sacrifice" material? (ie: they didn't pick randomly like they're supposed to or more controversy, the town comes to believe the creature didn't take her because her mind is broken) 

Either way they won't suspect it's something new to town until it's too late, dun dun DUUUUUNNNN~
[/quote]

[img]          http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-vihxiMBQtnI/UPf7SCFPivI/AAAAAAAABTU/lyt-p4He_9k/s1600/sam+and+dean+gasps.gif     [/img]