I don't think we can accommodate an Israel.

A lot of Israel's history requires British intervention and the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. The problem is, the Ottoman Empire collapsed just two weeks before where the RP is now. We also have well and established that Palestine primarily Arab, and that the movement to wrest it free from the Ottoman Empire was likewise primarily Arab.

Now, would there be Jews in this newly freed Palestine? Of course. Could there be Zionists? Maybe. They just wouldn't be a political majority.