[i]I'm[/i] going to be judging the sheets based off these qualities, in order from MOST to LEAST important:
[list][*] Alignment with RP themes. Reread the OOC post if you need a refresher.
[*] Possibility of interaction – How they might bounce off other characters in fun ways
[*] Macro-level Verisimilitude – Consistency with the setting, the school, etc.
[*] Internal Verisimilitude - How consistent the sheet is with itself
[*] Player RP history (not super important)
[*] Boring things like grammar and how well the sheet aligned with the template requirements (barely important)
[/list]

I won't be like, ranking the sheets from most awesome to least awesome or anything, moreso I'm going to be considering them in context with each other and coming up with what I think the most fun group might be.