I think it would be hard to argue that any of those different versions of, or expansions upon, those universes are equal or even in the same vicinity would be about impossible.  Which is probably why you just said there are problems with each, pointed out that LOTR wasn't a 1:1 adaptation of the books, and didn't mention the Witcher one.



Greatest.  WoW and Fortnite.  No.

Important, yes.

Groundbreaking, probably.

Greatest, no.

"And yet, every single character has been played by other people (and better, in almost every case) and in some cases they are the worst person who has played them. Also you're putting live action and voice acting together here. Also Daniel Day Lewis could play anyone and be perfect for it he's Daniel Day Lewis. "

Would love to see that.  Would also love to see Daniel Day Lewis play Monica Lewinsky while Monica Lewinsky plays Bill Clinton.

Saying someone shouldn't voice certain characters isn't saying they couldn't.  It's saying they would be a bad fit.  I was talking about acting.  But voicing works for the examples too.

Saying Kristen Stewart wouldn't play/voice as good a Joker or Willem Dafoe isn't saying she wouldn't be good at all.  It's saying Dafoe would be better.  And "you never know" isn't an argument.