I tried to find logs of the previous Battle Toyale's but they don't exist anymore.

They took place on a chatroom and I didn't save them because they didn't include a lot of traditional fighting.

The first Toyale had around 15 people in it and the majority of them (over half) were a part of the same clan. It was a group of super heroes and they wanted to do a pacifist run where everyone worked together and escaped the toy store.

The only two evil characters were me playing Katrina Masters (black-coded oni yakuza boss) and another guy called Hybris Penumbra (punk rock hillbilly cult leader) and they hated each other. We probably fought four or five times overall and this was our second meeting. So we spent the entire Toyale trying to kill each other in very slapstick Tom & Jerry ways that spilled over to antagonize the other characters and draw aggro.

Essentially to make them fight.

They didn't like that we weren't playing along with their plan and it started some OOC drama. Eventually I killed Hybris in a way that started an electrical fire and once the building started burning down the bulk of them chose not to respond and so that's why I say I was the winner, because I destroyed the building and won the only 1 on 1, and the majority of people who could stop me chose not to.

The second one was a year later and there were maybe 8-9 people? The guy who won it was named Trevor. He played the leader of a militia group in Neo Babylon so coming in he was a GI Joe and he commanded a bunch of army men NPCs. They spent most of their time grabbing equipment and rigging traps and things like that, I didn't participate so I didn't follow it closesly, but most of the action was more PvE and eventually Trevor blew up a large enough chunk of the store that everyone who wasn't dead just decided not to fight back.

So, typically a Battle Toyale is more comedy and chaos than traditional combat, and so far the winner has been the person who decides to destroy the store in a way that makes the other players surrender but those were all on chatrooms. A forum is an entirely different beast.