At the end of the day in these games we do try and work together but it [i]tends[/i] to be a first accepted gets the final say. [@Half Pint] gets the final say on this as I'm not a GM just the story guy, but I'd say what happens to Jean should be whatever will be most beneficial to the health of the Roleplay, and if they think both options are good, I'd say it should go to whoever was in position to use her first.

It sucks for the other person, but that do be the way these things to be doing.