[quote=deadlyfairy13] I thought we did......Anywho what if Ender stays were he is and Elsa ventures away? Maybe due to his refusal to beer out in the open..he goes to that witch and she ventures off? [/quote] Well I was thinking because their getting a long so well and she kinda likes him she'd let him sleep in or something while she goes out into the village to explore, that's how she could meet who ever it was that she meets who separates them. That way I don't really have to NPC him >w<