I think I can tell the reasons this is not as popular as it should be
1. you want a few people
2.fancy words
3.you want a few paragraphs per post, which is around advanced, most people looking here want free to mid casual (a few sentences to 1 paragraph minimum)
4.LACK OF MADDAFACKIN MAGIC

other than that I think its a good idea. ( I don't mind 1 and 2 all that much)