[quote=Yog Sothoth]
i feel like that would turn into who can post the fastest and also that would end up with whoever is the senior Quidditch player would always win. the coin flip makes it fair and not just determined by who is older. also explain to me how you would decide who catches the snitch?
[/quote]

Skill and quality of posts.

Skill should determine who wins, and only a small amount in part to luck. You believe everyone here is mature yes? Then they should be mature enough to not turn it into a 'who can post the fastest' match. And lets face it, the senior Quidditch player wouldn't always win. That's just nonsense. 

But as I stated earlier, whatever the GM decides, the GM decides and I will abide by whatever he wishes.

Sorry, but I dislike a large amount of luck determining the outcome of things, even if they would be in my favor.