[quote=Tick]
It also scares away good players or rejects decent to good players, either by not accepting what they did, or by killing their enthusiasm after the bio screening experience.
[/quote]

I'm experiencing this right now with an RP where I'm trying to get my character accepted. Enthusiasm for it has definitely pitfalled with the character rejections. I am a good sport and this is my sixth time trying to get it accepted, but at this point just having a single word off causing the rejection, and having a crapton of assumptions lopped on you for attempting to be creative within the setting has made me reconsider whether I should even continue. It was a good setting too. Shame, really.