[quote=Fabricant451]By the time SR3 came out, it had differentiated itself enough from GTA to be its own thing. And leagues better than both GTA 4 and 5. As far as 4 goes, it was just the natural extension of the crazy shit that you could do in 3. I will always love SR 4 just because I could fly around and cause mayhem with blaring. More open world games need to embrace the out-of-car music thing.
[/quote]

GTA 5 wins for the story. Saints Row 4 wins for the gameplay. Being able to nuke an entire part of the city with a single punch took the cake for me.