I would respond to every bit of that, but you wouldn't listen to it, to the actual meaning and not just what you perceive it to be. However, I will say that there was a weakness that is quite easy to manipulate, regardless of what you think. You never actually did anything, you just said what you would do and conveniently let him say whatever he wanted. You don't come out and say it, that's what marks you as an easy target. You lead them about in a circle, get the information you need, and then with this information, you can exploit a weakness that was revealed without ever having to tell him the actual weakness.

And don't say he's god-modding. He had the decency to make it obvious, and still give a way to kill his great big GM/OP things. You guys just have it run around, a thousand times smaller and thousand times more powerful, and continue saying he's bad. Don't be a hypocrite.