Brace yourself, because here come the vultures.
1) Can't have a Counter Spell ("Mystical Fire Typhoon"). They don't exist.
2) Some of your Level 3 monsters have point amounts that are WAY too high and no detriments to their effects. (Example: "Fairy of Shadows") There are only 5 Effect Monsters with 1800+ ATK, and ALL of them have a detriment in some form, and all but one of them have 600 or less DEF. Then there's "Arsenal Bug" with 2000 ATK & DEF, but it's almost useless in modern play. But still. Need some downsides, dude.
3) "Wielder of the Sword of Wind, Gale's" effect should read as follows: "When this card attacks a Defense Position monster: Inflict piercing damage to your opponent." It's much shorter, and more up-to-date with the modern terminology. But that's kind of minor.
4) "Set card" can refer to either a face-down monster, or a face-down Spell/Trap. This needs specification almost all across the board in your cards.
While it's on my mind, I haven't poked around on the YCM forum for a while, but for everyone's sake so I don't rip out their hopes and dreams, Empire, do you think you could pull up a link for that big long tutorial thing from YCM on fair card effects and proper terminology? If not I might try to find it again myself, but it's been, like, a year at least since I've been there. Of course I won't be AS strict as that page, but it's for everyone's self-improvement.
Rethel34
Member
Inverted Archery
- Last Seen: 2 yrs ago
- Old Guild Username: Rethel34
- Joined: 13 yrs ago
- Posts: 1322 (0.29 / day)
- VMs: 0
-
Username history
- Rethel34 13 yrs ago
Status
User has no status, yet
Bio
User has no bio, yet
Most Recent Posts
If any of you guys have Photoshop, I could try uploading the PSD file that I have that includes all different kinds of cards:
Normal Monster
Effect Monster
Ritual Monster
Fusion Monster
Synchro Monster
Dark Synchro
Xyz Monster
Normal Pendulum
Effect Pendulum
Ignis Monster
Spell Card
Trap Card
Just tell me if that interests you guys and I'll upload it to the first post. Granted, they aren't the best quality templates around, but they're something. If not, you could always just submit cards as text in the form I gave in the first post. Or you can use an Effect Monster on YCM or MSE and put " / Ignis" next to the Type and I'll make the monster in my temp. Whatever is popular among the people, I shall bend.
Normal Monster
Effect Monster
Ritual Monster
Fusion Monster
Synchro Monster
Dark Synchro
Xyz Monster
Normal Pendulum
Effect Pendulum
Ignis Monster
Spell Card
Trap Card
Just tell me if that interests you guys and I'll upload it to the first post. Granted, they aren't the best quality templates around, but they're something. If not, you could always just submit cards as text in the form I gave in the first post. Or you can use an Effect Monster on YCM or MSE and put " / Ignis" next to the Type and I'll make the monster in my temp. Whatever is popular among the people, I shall bend.
I'll IC post tomorrow morning. Kinda worn out now and not wanting to do much.
If its nuking effect worries you that much, use something along the lines of the Superheavy Samurais. It's only face-up Attack Position monsters, so as long as you're being cautious enough and defensive enough, then it shouldn't hurt you too much. And even if it wipes out all your monsters, it's only 2500 ATK and battle damage is halved if you activate either effect, so worst-case scenario is 1250 damage. Not what I'd call painfully threatening. So I'm sticking up for it.
@Char: Good to me.
@Gos: Good grief I keep getting ninja'd by you XD That's fine. I'm patient. I might not get this thread finished until then.
@Gos: Good grief I keep getting ninja'd by you XD That's fine. I'm patient. I might not get this thread finished until then.
@Tree: Nah, you're good. I don't mind giving an extra demonstration. Sometimes it helps peoples. :)
@Char: How about 500 for each material if all three? Then you have a 4000 monster. Then you say it can't attack your opponent directly this turn and be done?
@Char: How about 500 for each material if all three? Then you have a 4000 monster. Then you say it can't attack your opponent directly this turn and be done?
Sorry, Gos.
@Empire: Fair enough, I suppose. I'll leave it to Charak to see if he agrees.
@ Scar: Sorry for ignoring. Charak's card blew everything up. Uhm . . . maybe a tad OP'd, but then again, maybe not. I'll see what everyone else thinks.
@Empire: Fair enough, I suppose. I'll leave it to Charak to see if he agrees.
@ Scar: Sorry for ignoring. Charak's card blew everything up. Uhm . . . maybe a tad OP'd, but then again, maybe not. I'll see what everyone else thinks.
Hi, mr. malm
Alright, so, to show what is common among Rank 4 Xyz Monsters . . .
Now, maybe not all of those are amazing, but a number of those not only have good points, but also have REALLY good effects. And how many are at all touching the Limited list? Not a one. I MIGHT hit this thing with a Semi. (As in, Semi-Limit it . . . not run it over with a tractor trailer) Maybe. No guarantees.
4500 is until the end phase. Compare against Night Papilloperative. Or Dark Rebellion Xyz Dragon. I see Charak's monster as on-par.
Now, maybe not all of those are amazing, but a number of those not only have good points, but also have REALLY good effects. And how many are at all touching the Limited list? Not a one. I MIGHT hit this thing with a Semi. (As in, Semi-Limit it . . . not run it over with a tractor trailer) Maybe. No guarantees.
4500 is until the end phase. Compare against Night Papilloperative. Or Dark Rebellion Xyz Dragon. I see Charak's monster as on-par.
Rank 4 Xyz Monster that requires 3 Xyz Materials. . . .
I've seen a Rank 4 that requires 2 non-specific materials that has 2500 ATK. It's called Utopia.
I've seen a Rank 4 that requires 2 non-specific materials that has 2500 ATK. It's called Utopia.
© 2007-2026