ERode said
BUT IT MAKES SO MUCH SENSE!We know that Grimm are attracted to things with souls, and would aim to eat humans. If we then extrapolate and assume Grimm gain their animal motifs because that's what they've consumed before (lesser souls in the form of animals/wildlife) then the Faunus could have popped up shortly before the advent of Dust, in the form of super-strong Grimm who have eaten enough humans to gain a soul of their own and a human-ish form!
The Irish Tree said
...What I REALLY wanna know is if there's a faunus for every animal imaginable...IF THERE'S A MANTIS SHRIMP KIND, WE'RE FUCKING DED. D.E.D. DEDYOU SEE THIS ROCK? HE COULD THROW IT THROUGH YOUR BRAIN MANG.But I mainly ask because cat faunus are a thing, but do they come in all the different species of cats? Callico, Persian, other cat types? MONTY, WE DEMAND ANSWERS, WHICH IS WHY WE DON'T ASK!
ERode said
That doesn't make much sense though, because that would mean that Faunus were complete retards incapable of making their own kingdoms. In the Creation Myth, it stated that Humans were made from dust, and Grimm then followed. Then, HUMANS made their kingdoms...and where exactly were the faunus in all this?What if...they were originally Grimm who have regained their soul (think about how all the Grimm are based off animals)...THE MYSTERY IS REAL.
The Irish Tree said
...Seriously, if they were mules, then that means that beastiality was not only a thing, IT WAS A BIG THING! Get your head outta the gutter with that. Now, a more likely thing was that they were some sorta offshoot from human evolution, likely taking on traits of certain animals through evolutionary magic that DOES NOT work that way. But hey, it's Monty's setting, the beautiful thing about settings is that you could make air into jelly and it'd be alright as long as they breath jelly. Moral of the story: DAMMIT MONTY, LEARN TO BIOLOGY!
ERode said
EXACTLY. That's why Arara's so suspicious about them. Humans and Grimm were both mentioned in the Creation Myth, so what the hell are Faunus? Just another evolution of an animal? Except why is there such a massive variety of them?
Essentially, she sees them as sub-human mutants, or some advanced ape. Maybe Faunus were originally the creation of humans, which was why humans thought themselves as superior the first place.
The Irish Tree said
Well, going back to donkeys and horses, they are genetically compatible due to similar enough genes, so if we were to draw a real world comparison aside from that, we'd be pretty hard-pressed. Think of it like how Superman can have kids, even though he's not anywhere close to being human in terms of genetic code. It works because the setting says it does, and unless Monty gets into the nitty gritty, we might never get a definite answer.
The Irish Tree said
...Maybe it just works like Mules, where you get the best of both but the chromosomes for reproduction get all kinds of fudged up so they can't do the do?
ERode said
Oh yeah, I've been wondering....What exactly happens when a human and a faunus have babies?
The Irish Tree said
I dare say you'd need a doctor if both came out at once, I mean heck, that'd just be painful...We ARE talking about passing a kidney stone and peeing, right?