@Hunter of Dreams I'm so sorry I didn't catch this post!
I imagine your character is still in the human world living her normal life at this moment... though it won't be for long ;) Perhaps they meet during a halloween party or christmas or something when the veil between worlds are thinnest?
Or it could be any really iconic time... Like a Mayfair dance, or her birthday, or during a Harvest moon.
I like the idea of there being lots of people around though and he singles her out. But honestly I'm up for anything if you prefer something else!