Laguna beach was atypically quiet, even for a Thursday, but then again, half the town was surely still asleep by the time Rob and Sam had made it over there. It barely constituted Thursday at all.
Rob wasn’t much for early mornings. Especially not mornings which began a drive in the darkness. The sun didn’t start peaking over the eastward mountains until after the two had parked and were stretching.
“I cannot believe you got me out here to do this shit,” Rob muttered under his breath, as he stretched his calves out. He had tried to be decent to his body over the years, but all of that footwork underneath the kit meant his calves were a chronic problem. He didn’t hear a response from Sam, and was about to repeat himself when Sam silently slid a tincture into his free hand.
“What’s this?”
“Pot, dumbass.”
“It’s maybe seven in the morning.”
Sam shrugged, then held his shoulders in tension for a bit before moving to twisting his back. “Then just a little bit. Helps with withdrawal.”
That comment stopped Rob dead in his tracks.
“Dude,” Sam started, “Don’t start. Your hands shake hands under the table” He pointed at him. “You’re already sweating.”
“It’s warm out,” Rob shrugged.
“Sure, bud,” Sam continued. “I don’t care. I’ve just seen it all before. The anxiety gets worse before it gets better.”
Rob thought quietly for a moment. “I didn’t think I was that deep.”
“Hey—I told you to cut that shit out,” Sam shot back. He locked up the car and led Rob to the start of the sidewalk. They had two miles to go before they made it to the breakfast spot Sam had picked out. Run there, walk back; that was the plan. Before starting off, Sam turned back to Rob. “You are where you’re at. That’s it. Don’t fucking overthink it.”
“I didn’t take you for a philosopher.”
“I’m not—that’s you.”
With that, Sam turned and jogged off. Rob would shortly follow, after using the tincture.
Sam was right, in his own prickly way. Call it the benefit of a simpler go at things over the year, but he was plainly confident in his own way. All instinct. Something of a welcome salve for Rob.
Tomorrow was In Bloom’s first show in a decade. A sold out show. And soon after, the road waited. Traveling, tour busses, riders, support acts, the works. A world that Rob used to know very well but could only look back on now like a half-remembered dream. He wondered how the others felt about it. Whether it was a sweater that still fit after all these years — or one that you can’t believe you ever wore in the first place.
Rob tried his best to brush the thoughts aside as he rain along the coast. The air here was different than back at home. It was warmer, and not just in temperature. Seattle was a cool green hue wherever you went, whereas here? The orange sun was so familiar, it felt paternal.
Home indeed.
—
He hurt more than he thought he would when they finally arrived, but two miles was a solid return to form and he was looking forward to running the two remaining miles back. He was sat across from Sam on the back patio of a breakfast diner. The air was perfect—sea salt, cheap oil, and bacon. Not much else you could ask for.
Rob poked at his remaining eggs while Sam messed around idly at his phone. The conversation had run dry a bit earlier than expected, and so Sam was taking the opportunity to find and show Rob some of the online reaction to the new single.
If anything made him feel anachronistic to everything going on, it was social media. He had never used it much at any age, and while it had been around his whole life, in his mind, he could better feel the impact of the music in the crowds and, more bluntly, in the dollars and cents than in the number of video essays generated or impressions gained.
But from what Sam was showing him, the crowds he was about to see might look a little different than they used to. Some of the people he knew were there, in the reactions. The types of fans who would quietly collect merch and talk you ear off about other bands they loved, if they could corner you. But the in the multitude of short videos Rob was shown, the crowd seemed different. Younger, of course (no surprise there) but also seemingly more interested in the meta of it all.
Which was the exact thing Rob was hoping to avoid.
“When I tell you this was the clapback," one person said — their dorm room clear in the background. “Just cause she didn’t say anything doesn’t mean she didn’t have Everything just waiting to clock his ass.”
Sam scrolled to the once one flatly once he realized they were probably talking about Rob.
The phone in his pocket mercifully rang, and he excused himself to take it. He walked down the stairs onto the beach before answering.
“Rob, hi! Danielle, from Blackout Records? We spoke earlier.”
“Of course, yeah,” Rob said. “What’s up?”
“I spoke with Evan earlier — he really didn’t think I should tell you this — but I did — and it’s really my job — so I wanted to get you caught up on something coming up.”
Rob’s heart immediately quickened. The publicist is calling me, he thought. When has that ever been a good thing?
“Sure, uh,” Rob stammered out. “Shoot.”
“Well, some metadata leaked from MAE on a drop for Monday.” She paused for a response, and when she got none, continued: “She’s got a song coming out tomorrow. Supposedly. Or at least one of the distribution platforms seems to think so. And I wanted to give you a head’s up, because some of the lyrics leaked, and uh—“
“Let me guess,” Rob sighed. “They’re about me.”
“…who’s to say. But we think it’s possible people may—“
“Look, Danielle,” Rob cut off. His body continued to tense, and he felt himself already reaching for the tincture in his pocket. “I’m looking forward to working with you and all, but if you could shoot straight with me on your opinions, I’d really appreciate it.”
Silence on the end of the line, for a moment, then a breath.
“She isn’t being very subtle,” Danielle finally responded. “We were hoping with the show and all, you might could give her a call and see if this is something we should anticipate.”
“You want me to call MAE and ask her to move her release?”
“You said you wanted me to shoot straight, yeah?”
“Yes.”
“Well,” Danielle began, “Yes. MAE’s got exponentially more followers and any commentary she has on your failed marriage from her is going to going to drown us for a day or two.”
“A day or two?” Rob asked. “I was expecting months. Also, ouch.”
“Hey, you told me to. And these things don’t really stick around as long. It’s more of a sparring war. She’ll comment and that will be the last word until we comment. Then that’ll be it, and people forget quickly until their algorithms update them.”
Rob was about to respond when a phone camera was very suddently in his face.
“Oh my god, I can’t believe I found him!”
Rob took a few instinctive steps back, only to find the phone kept coming closer. On the other side, what looked like a local girl who couldn’t have been any older than twenty kept approaching — eyes on the phone, looking at Rob only through the surrogate. He was so caught off guard, he initially didn’t say anything.
“Literally out here in the wild,” the girl said, “You look stressed, Rob. Message for the MAE girlies before she eats tomorrow?”
“I — what?” Rob finally said. His own phone dropped from his year. “I’m sorry, I’m on a call.”
“Oooo! Which one, which one?”
“Which what?” Rob shot back.
“The mother of your baby, or your precious Jane?”
“Alright, back the fuck up,” Sam shot out. He had mercifully stuck himself in between Rob and the girl. “Playtime’s over.”
“Woah, chill,” she said, dropping the phone just for a moment before raising it again. “Who even are you, anyways?”
While Sam continued to chase off the girl, Rob liftted his own phone back to his ear. “Sorry, Danielle. I don’t really know what just happened.”
“I could hear it on my end,” she replied. “This is exactly what I want to avoid. Do you think you can give her a call?”
“…I’ll see what I can do.”
---
A few hours later, Rob found himself pacing the neighborhood outside the rental home. They had ran back as they planned, but the mood was considerably less relaxed.
“These fuckin’ kids, man,” Sam had told him on the ride home. “Can’t even look you in the eye but wanna shove a camera down your throat.”
Rob tried to laugh it off then, but even now, it was hard to tell what was withdrawal and what was genuine fear. It almost felt like rigor mortis had set in, with how tense he was feeling.
Maybe a valid feeling for a dead man walking.
“Hello?” Mae’s voice finally came, after the third try. More and more these days, Rob had to call her multiple times in a row before she’d answer. Probably with all of the studio work she was putting in, but it certainly didn’t help.
“Hey, sorry to bother you,” Rob started. “I just had a weird interaction with I think a fan of yours and, I just wanted to ask, if something happening tomorrow?”
Rob had figured blaming the fan would be easy cover for ‘my label wants me to collect info on you,’ and given how long Mae paused before responding, it seems it was needed.
“I think so, yeah. I was between Friday and Monday but my group said Friday would be more impactful.”
“Any chance you can change that?”
“I’m sorry?”
“Well,” Rob started. He figured he had no other option but to just level with her. “My band has its first show in ten years tomorrow. Secret show, but word’s gotten out. It’d mean a lot to have that day if you can still move yours to Monday.”
“…maybe you’re right,” she sighed. “Plus, honestly I’m glad you’re calling, because I wanted to give you a head’s up on this one. The lyrics are going to feel a bit familiar.”
“You wrote a song about me.”
“About us.”
Silent tears began to well in his eyes. “Mae, we talked about this years ago. I’ve kept my word, I need you to keep yours.”
“I am, Robby, I am. I don’t call you names, I don’t ask people to hate you, nothing like that.”
“Well, according to one of your fans, you’re going to shred me.”
“They’re protective of me,” Mae defended. “It’s not personal, I’m sure your fans don’t love me very much.”
“There are a thousand of your fans for every ten of ours,” Rob shot back. “It’s not a fair comparison.”
“It’s my life, I have a right to speak on it.”
“Don’t pull that shit with me, Mae.” Rob practically seethed. “This isn’t about your fucking agency, because you have more power and influence than any of us combined. This is about Elle. It always has been.”
“…Okay, Rob. Take a breath. I'll have my team call the distributors and push it to Sunday night. If this weekend is that important to your little reunion, you can have it. But you need to stop bring up Elle the moment you need something from me.”
“She’s the reason we agreed not to do this publically.”
“All the same. Look — I have to go, I’m heading into a media day. And now I’m going to make a bunch of phone calls to move the dates and try and make you happy again. Not like I ever could.”
The line went dead after that.
---
Rob stayed outside for a good while after that, until Sam came to get him back inside. He had been sat on the front porch chair, watching cars go by.
After the morning he had had, it was all he wanted to do. He didn’t want to think about the concert, or the next few days. He didn’t want to think about the lyrics Danielle texted him from his ex-wife’s new single — he didn’t even read them, not yet. What was the point? Whatever she said, was going to be the biggest thing in the world.
And Mae, always the innocent giant, would rain down hellfire on him just by writing a handful of lyrics. The world would do the rest. In a weird way, he felt like Frankenstein in the ice. Waiting for his monster to come kill him. The monster of his own making. Action, meet consequence.
By the time Sam got him, he wordlessly followed. And for the first time in perhaps, ever, Sam looked worried.
“Hey man, you good?” He asked as the two headed back inside.
“Yeah, why?”
“I dunno. You just look like you aren’t thinking, for once.”
Rob shrugged.
On the way back inside, he briefly saw Jane. She was headed upstairs, sandwich in hand, no doubt getting herself ready for rehearsal.
And in that moment, he prayed every ounce of shit that came out of Mae’s side of this would hit him instead of her. J had been through enough.
“I’m headed downstairs,” Rob called to Sam. “I need to hit something.”
---
Halfway through playing Veins, the morning was already a mercifully distant memory. There was an energy with In Bloom that could never be replicated in any other band Rob had played with.
When In Bloom played, four California kids from decades ago were alive again. Innocent, young, and beautiful. There was nothing else like it.
“Well, I think we still got it.” J said.
Rob couldn’t stifle a laugh and a smile. “That felt great,” he said, beeming. “God, I missed this.”
He looked over to Austin, who cracked the first genuine smile he’d seen in a days. Maybe since they first got here.
“Alright, try this one on for size.” Rob shouted into his microphone, and began to play. He immediately launched into an older track from them — long before even the first tour was a idea. He had ripped the syncopated drums out of the Arctic Monkeys record he had been listening to that summer. A sort of hard rock version of a latin clave.
The rest of the song sounded little like the original influence (J’s voice lent a texture that was at times furtive and at others, beautifully baleful) but — judging by the look in their eyes — they also knew this one immediately.
From there, the practice went on — and on, and on.
At a certain point, Rob had lost all track of time. A few hours in, some takeout had appeared downstairs, and Rob could barely get a few bites in before starting up again.
And for a moment, a beautiful, ephemeral moment, they were all 18 again.
At one point, Rob found himself laying on his back on the floor in the center of the room, knees raised and foot crossed over. The rest of the band had joined him on the rug — Sam with his back against the wall, scarfing down an egg roll. Austin sat cris-crossed and watching, as Rob was, J sing. She had an acoustic in her hand and was playing something soft and beautiful. He couldn’t tell what it was, but laying there, watching her strumming hand almost dance along the strings, he would have sworn it was the most beautiful song in the world.
Towards the end of the song, his eyes raised from her hands to meet her eyes.
They were already looking to his.
Eventually, the evening wrapped up, and everyone had begun packing things up. They had tracked five or six songs (Rob had lost count) and a few covers. A mix of new stuff, old stuff — just about anything really. He wasn’t sure what Evan would make of it, but at least he could be happy In Bloom was more than ready to take on tomorrow.
Rob didn’t want the night to end, but he was struggling to keep his eyes open. His eyes looked down towards his hand, keeping him propped up from the floor. He could just make out the gentle tremor in his pinky.
He’d need to smoke a bit before bed.
“I think I’m gonna call it,” he said, rising up to his feet. Sam and Austin were in the corner, talking about mix busses and signal chains. Meanwhile, Rob stole a quick moment with J while he could.
“Hey, if you’re free this weekend I was thinking about heading to Joshua Tree,” he said, a warm smile already building on his lips. “Somewhere without cell service. Maybe rent a little place for a night and just dissapear for a bit after the show?”
He knew all he wanted to do this weekend was get away, and he was hoping J would, too. She deserved it.
He wished his life had been quieter so he could focus more on hers. J was so different now, had done so much work on herself… he wanted to get to know her again. The same people but differnet — changed by time but still the same underneath it all. Maybe they really could start over fresh. Equal terms, happy and healthy—
—just then, his smart watch pinged. Glancing down, he could see Danielle had texted him two words: Call Me.
The pang of fear that shot through him at that thought kept him from thinking of the weekend any further. He would only hope she’d say yes.
“Sorry, it’s Danielle,” he apologized. His eyes lingered on hers a hair too long before he continued. “Let me know, yeah? I’d love to get away—” his voice shrinking before he could say ‘with you,’ as well.
He excused himself and made his way upstairs.
As soon as the door behind him closed, he rushed to shower — taking several hits off a pen before, and particularly after. He felt like he was rushing towards a car crash, but he just wished the car would speed up faster and get it over with.
All too soon, he was sat at the end of his bed, eyes cast outward to the night sky past the windowsill. The mountains carved beautiful curves into the starry night sky. It was a beautiful evening.
“Hi Rob,” came Danielle’s voice after two rings. He was put on edge immediately. There was pity dripping from her after only two words. That couldn’t have meant anything good.
“Danielle,” Rob replied, flat. “That bad, huh?”
“What do you mean?”
“You wanted me to call you and you sound like you’re about to tell me someone died.”
“I should work on my tone, then,” she replied. She was taking her publicist tone now, but rer hesistation only further confirmed his fears. “I pulled some strings with Spotify. Me and someone in their distribution department were in the same sorority.”
“Sound like a pretty successful one.”
“I got the track early,” she continued. “I can’t send it to you, I made some pretty aggressive promises, but I can play it for you now, if you’d like.”
This time, it was Rob’s turn to take a beat.
“…do you think I should?” he asked.
“I’ve been wondering that all day,” she said. “I got this before we spoke this morning, actually. But I talked to my Dad about it and he agreed.”
“I’m sorry?”
“My, uh—” the publicist voice dropped again, and Danielle continued: “My parents split when I was very young. They told me they grew apart and adults are complicated, but I’ve pretty much always known they only stayed together as long as they did for me. Anyways — when I was older, I finally got her to tell me the truth.”
Rob’s voice grew small. “What was the truth?”
“She said it was because one day she realized that she was anyways going to be second. Before they had ever met, Dad had loved a woman that had left him. He hadn’t seen her in decades, he was always loyal to her and loved her as much as he could… but he still held space for her. Somewhere. Despite it all.”
Rob couldn’t say anything anymore.
“Anyways, of course it’s a bit personal for me. And I’m sure this is for you. We’ve all moved on, my parents are great friends and I love them both. I don’t know what’s gone on between you and Mae but I don’t think you deserve to hear it for the first time with millions of other people.”
Tears had already welled up in Robs eyes. “Play it.”
“Sure.”
After a moment, a soft, gentle piano filled the air. Nothing else. And atop, she sang something beautiful, quiet. and devastating:
You held me like a promise
you forgot to keep.
I used to listen to you breathing,
when you were talking in your sleep.
To a ghost.
In a quiet room.
Just a quiet room.
Mae had tried her best to balance the truth with anonymity, but anyone with eyes could see that it was Rob she sang about.
And as he listened, the dam finally broke.
He pressed the heels of his hands hard into his eyes, but it couldn’t stop the tears. He shuttered and shook in quiet grief, his tears falling freely into his lap. He rocked, gently, but it was no comfort.
He couldn’t hide it from himself anymore. She was right.
J never left his heart. She never could. Mae could only ever take up as much space in him as he’d allow, and he’d never allow it all. And he loved her, and he married her, and he had a beautiful daughter with her, but he was hers but she was never fully his.
And now one day, Elle would know. And in a few days, everyone else would, too. There would be no running from this. Not now, not ever.
“Rob?” Danielle had asked. The song had ended a few minutes ago, but his phone stayed muted. He had no words to speak.
“I know you’re muted, you don’t have to say anything. Just… take care of yourself. Call me tomorrow.”
She hesitated a long moment. “There’s an after, after this. Remember that. Goodnight.”
The line disconnected.
And Rob, stripped bare, wept.
Rob wasn’t much for early mornings. Especially not mornings which began a drive in the darkness. The sun didn’t start peaking over the eastward mountains until after the two had parked and were stretching.
“I cannot believe you got me out here to do this shit,” Rob muttered under his breath, as he stretched his calves out. He had tried to be decent to his body over the years, but all of that footwork underneath the kit meant his calves were a chronic problem. He didn’t hear a response from Sam, and was about to repeat himself when Sam silently slid a tincture into his free hand.
“What’s this?”
“Pot, dumbass.”
“It’s maybe seven in the morning.”
Sam shrugged, then held his shoulders in tension for a bit before moving to twisting his back. “Then just a little bit. Helps with withdrawal.”
That comment stopped Rob dead in his tracks.
“Dude,” Sam started, “Don’t start. Your hands shake hands under the table” He pointed at him. “You’re already sweating.”
“It’s warm out,” Rob shrugged.
“Sure, bud,” Sam continued. “I don’t care. I’ve just seen it all before. The anxiety gets worse before it gets better.”
Rob thought quietly for a moment. “I didn’t think I was that deep.”
“Hey—I told you to cut that shit out,” Sam shot back. He locked up the car and led Rob to the start of the sidewalk. They had two miles to go before they made it to the breakfast spot Sam had picked out. Run there, walk back; that was the plan. Before starting off, Sam turned back to Rob. “You are where you’re at. That’s it. Don’t fucking overthink it.”
“I didn’t take you for a philosopher.”
“I’m not—that’s you.”
With that, Sam turned and jogged off. Rob would shortly follow, after using the tincture.
Sam was right, in his own prickly way. Call it the benefit of a simpler go at things over the year, but he was plainly confident in his own way. All instinct. Something of a welcome salve for Rob.
Tomorrow was In Bloom’s first show in a decade. A sold out show. And soon after, the road waited. Traveling, tour busses, riders, support acts, the works. A world that Rob used to know very well but could only look back on now like a half-remembered dream. He wondered how the others felt about it. Whether it was a sweater that still fit after all these years — or one that you can’t believe you ever wore in the first place.
Rob tried his best to brush the thoughts aside as he rain along the coast. The air here was different than back at home. It was warmer, and not just in temperature. Seattle was a cool green hue wherever you went, whereas here? The orange sun was so familiar, it felt paternal.
Home indeed.
—
He hurt more than he thought he would when they finally arrived, but two miles was a solid return to form and he was looking forward to running the two remaining miles back. He was sat across from Sam on the back patio of a breakfast diner. The air was perfect—sea salt, cheap oil, and bacon. Not much else you could ask for.
Rob poked at his remaining eggs while Sam messed around idly at his phone. The conversation had run dry a bit earlier than expected, and so Sam was taking the opportunity to find and show Rob some of the online reaction to the new single.
If anything made him feel anachronistic to everything going on, it was social media. He had never used it much at any age, and while it had been around his whole life, in his mind, he could better feel the impact of the music in the crowds and, more bluntly, in the dollars and cents than in the number of video essays generated or impressions gained.
But from what Sam was showing him, the crowds he was about to see might look a little different than they used to. Some of the people he knew were there, in the reactions. The types of fans who would quietly collect merch and talk you ear off about other bands they loved, if they could corner you. But the in the multitude of short videos Rob was shown, the crowd seemed different. Younger, of course (no surprise there) but also seemingly more interested in the meta of it all.
Which was the exact thing Rob was hoping to avoid.
“When I tell you this was the clapback," one person said — their dorm room clear in the background. “Just cause she didn’t say anything doesn’t mean she didn’t have Everything just waiting to clock his ass.”
Sam scrolled to the once one flatly once he realized they were probably talking about Rob.
The phone in his pocket mercifully rang, and he excused himself to take it. He walked down the stairs onto the beach before answering.
“Rob, hi! Danielle, from Blackout Records? We spoke earlier.”
“Of course, yeah,” Rob said. “What’s up?”
“I spoke with Evan earlier — he really didn’t think I should tell you this — but I did — and it’s really my job — so I wanted to get you caught up on something coming up.”
Rob’s heart immediately quickened. The publicist is calling me, he thought. When has that ever been a good thing?
“Sure, uh,” Rob stammered out. “Shoot.”
“Well, some metadata leaked from MAE on a drop for Monday.” She paused for a response, and when she got none, continued: “She’s got a song coming out tomorrow. Supposedly. Or at least one of the distribution platforms seems to think so. And I wanted to give you a head’s up, because some of the lyrics leaked, and uh—“
“Let me guess,” Rob sighed. “They’re about me.”
“…who’s to say. But we think it’s possible people may—“
“Look, Danielle,” Rob cut off. His body continued to tense, and he felt himself already reaching for the tincture in his pocket. “I’m looking forward to working with you and all, but if you could shoot straight with me on your opinions, I’d really appreciate it.”
Silence on the end of the line, for a moment, then a breath.
“She isn’t being very subtle,” Danielle finally responded. “We were hoping with the show and all, you might could give her a call and see if this is something we should anticipate.”
“You want me to call MAE and ask her to move her release?”
“You said you wanted me to shoot straight, yeah?”
“Yes.”
“Well,” Danielle began, “Yes. MAE’s got exponentially more followers and any commentary she has on your failed marriage from her is going to going to drown us for a day or two.”
“A day or two?” Rob asked. “I was expecting months. Also, ouch.”
“Hey, you told me to. And these things don’t really stick around as long. It’s more of a sparring war. She’ll comment and that will be the last word until we comment. Then that’ll be it, and people forget quickly until their algorithms update them.”
Rob was about to respond when a phone camera was very suddently in his face.
“Oh my god, I can’t believe I found him!”
Rob took a few instinctive steps back, only to find the phone kept coming closer. On the other side, what looked like a local girl who couldn’t have been any older than twenty kept approaching — eyes on the phone, looking at Rob only through the surrogate. He was so caught off guard, he initially didn’t say anything.
“Literally out here in the wild,” the girl said, “You look stressed, Rob. Message for the MAE girlies before she eats tomorrow?”
“I — what?” Rob finally said. His own phone dropped from his year. “I’m sorry, I’m on a call.”
“Oooo! Which one, which one?”
“Which what?” Rob shot back.
“The mother of your baby, or your precious Jane?”
“Alright, back the fuck up,” Sam shot out. He had mercifully stuck himself in between Rob and the girl. “Playtime’s over.”
“Woah, chill,” she said, dropping the phone just for a moment before raising it again. “Who even are you, anyways?”
While Sam continued to chase off the girl, Rob liftted his own phone back to his ear. “Sorry, Danielle. I don’t really know what just happened.”
“I could hear it on my end,” she replied. “This is exactly what I want to avoid. Do you think you can give her a call?”
“…I’ll see what I can do.”
---
A few hours later, Rob found himself pacing the neighborhood outside the rental home. They had ran back as they planned, but the mood was considerably less relaxed.
“These fuckin’ kids, man,” Sam had told him on the ride home. “Can’t even look you in the eye but wanna shove a camera down your throat.”
Rob tried to laugh it off then, but even now, it was hard to tell what was withdrawal and what was genuine fear. It almost felt like rigor mortis had set in, with how tense he was feeling.
Maybe a valid feeling for a dead man walking.
“Hello?” Mae’s voice finally came, after the third try. More and more these days, Rob had to call her multiple times in a row before she’d answer. Probably with all of the studio work she was putting in, but it certainly didn’t help.
“Hey, sorry to bother you,” Rob started. “I just had a weird interaction with I think a fan of yours and, I just wanted to ask, if something happening tomorrow?”
Rob had figured blaming the fan would be easy cover for ‘my label wants me to collect info on you,’ and given how long Mae paused before responding, it seems it was needed.
“I think so, yeah. I was between Friday and Monday but my group said Friday would be more impactful.”
“Any chance you can change that?”
“I’m sorry?”
“Well,” Rob started. He figured he had no other option but to just level with her. “My band has its first show in ten years tomorrow. Secret show, but word’s gotten out. It’d mean a lot to have that day if you can still move yours to Monday.”
“…maybe you’re right,” she sighed. “Plus, honestly I’m glad you’re calling, because I wanted to give you a head’s up on this one. The lyrics are going to feel a bit familiar.”
“You wrote a song about me.”
“About us.”
Silent tears began to well in his eyes. “Mae, we talked about this years ago. I’ve kept my word, I need you to keep yours.”
“I am, Robby, I am. I don’t call you names, I don’t ask people to hate you, nothing like that.”
“Well, according to one of your fans, you’re going to shred me.”
“They’re protective of me,” Mae defended. “It’s not personal, I’m sure your fans don’t love me very much.”
“There are a thousand of your fans for every ten of ours,” Rob shot back. “It’s not a fair comparison.”
“It’s my life, I have a right to speak on it.”
“Don’t pull that shit with me, Mae.” Rob practically seethed. “This isn’t about your fucking agency, because you have more power and influence than any of us combined. This is about Elle. It always has been.”
“…Okay, Rob. Take a breath. I'll have my team call the distributors and push it to Sunday night. If this weekend is that important to your little reunion, you can have it. But you need to stop bring up Elle the moment you need something from me.”
“She’s the reason we agreed not to do this publically.”
“All the same. Look — I have to go, I’m heading into a media day. And now I’m going to make a bunch of phone calls to move the dates and try and make you happy again. Not like I ever could.”
The line went dead after that.
---
Rob stayed outside for a good while after that, until Sam came to get him back inside. He had been sat on the front porch chair, watching cars go by.
After the morning he had had, it was all he wanted to do. He didn’t want to think about the concert, or the next few days. He didn’t want to think about the lyrics Danielle texted him from his ex-wife’s new single — he didn’t even read them, not yet. What was the point? Whatever she said, was going to be the biggest thing in the world.
And Mae, always the innocent giant, would rain down hellfire on him just by writing a handful of lyrics. The world would do the rest. In a weird way, he felt like Frankenstein in the ice. Waiting for his monster to come kill him. The monster of his own making. Action, meet consequence.
By the time Sam got him, he wordlessly followed. And for the first time in perhaps, ever, Sam looked worried.
“Hey man, you good?” He asked as the two headed back inside.
“Yeah, why?”
“I dunno. You just look like you aren’t thinking, for once.”
Rob shrugged.
On the way back inside, he briefly saw Jane. She was headed upstairs, sandwich in hand, no doubt getting herself ready for rehearsal.
And in that moment, he prayed every ounce of shit that came out of Mae’s side of this would hit him instead of her. J had been through enough.
“I’m headed downstairs,” Rob called to Sam. “I need to hit something.”
---
Halfway through playing Veins, the morning was already a mercifully distant memory. There was an energy with In Bloom that could never be replicated in any other band Rob had played with.
When In Bloom played, four California kids from decades ago were alive again. Innocent, young, and beautiful. There was nothing else like it.
“Well, I think we still got it.” J said.
Rob couldn’t stifle a laugh and a smile. “That felt great,” he said, beeming. “God, I missed this.”
He looked over to Austin, who cracked the first genuine smile he’d seen in a days. Maybe since they first got here.
“Alright, try this one on for size.” Rob shouted into his microphone, and began to play. He immediately launched into an older track from them — long before even the first tour was a idea. He had ripped the syncopated drums out of the Arctic Monkeys record he had been listening to that summer. A sort of hard rock version of a latin clave.
The rest of the song sounded little like the original influence (J’s voice lent a texture that was at times furtive and at others, beautifully baleful) but — judging by the look in their eyes — they also knew this one immediately.
From there, the practice went on — and on, and on.
At a certain point, Rob had lost all track of time. A few hours in, some takeout had appeared downstairs, and Rob could barely get a few bites in before starting up again.
And for a moment, a beautiful, ephemeral moment, they were all 18 again.
At one point, Rob found himself laying on his back on the floor in the center of the room, knees raised and foot crossed over. The rest of the band had joined him on the rug — Sam with his back against the wall, scarfing down an egg roll. Austin sat cris-crossed and watching, as Rob was, J sing. She had an acoustic in her hand and was playing something soft and beautiful. He couldn’t tell what it was, but laying there, watching her strumming hand almost dance along the strings, he would have sworn it was the most beautiful song in the world.
Towards the end of the song, his eyes raised from her hands to meet her eyes.
They were already looking to his.
Eventually, the evening wrapped up, and everyone had begun packing things up. They had tracked five or six songs (Rob had lost count) and a few covers. A mix of new stuff, old stuff — just about anything really. He wasn’t sure what Evan would make of it, but at least he could be happy In Bloom was more than ready to take on tomorrow.
Rob didn’t want the night to end, but he was struggling to keep his eyes open. His eyes looked down towards his hand, keeping him propped up from the floor. He could just make out the gentle tremor in his pinky.
He’d need to smoke a bit before bed.
“I think I’m gonna call it,” he said, rising up to his feet. Sam and Austin were in the corner, talking about mix busses and signal chains. Meanwhile, Rob stole a quick moment with J while he could.
“Hey, if you’re free this weekend I was thinking about heading to Joshua Tree,” he said, a warm smile already building on his lips. “Somewhere without cell service. Maybe rent a little place for a night and just dissapear for a bit after the show?”
He knew all he wanted to do this weekend was get away, and he was hoping J would, too. She deserved it.
He wished his life had been quieter so he could focus more on hers. J was so different now, had done so much work on herself… he wanted to get to know her again. The same people but differnet — changed by time but still the same underneath it all. Maybe they really could start over fresh. Equal terms, happy and healthy—
—just then, his smart watch pinged. Glancing down, he could see Danielle had texted him two words: Call Me.
The pang of fear that shot through him at that thought kept him from thinking of the weekend any further. He would only hope she’d say yes.
“Sorry, it’s Danielle,” he apologized. His eyes lingered on hers a hair too long before he continued. “Let me know, yeah? I’d love to get away—” his voice shrinking before he could say ‘with you,’ as well.
He excused himself and made his way upstairs.
As soon as the door behind him closed, he rushed to shower — taking several hits off a pen before, and particularly after. He felt like he was rushing towards a car crash, but he just wished the car would speed up faster and get it over with.
All too soon, he was sat at the end of his bed, eyes cast outward to the night sky past the windowsill. The mountains carved beautiful curves into the starry night sky. It was a beautiful evening.
“Hi Rob,” came Danielle’s voice after two rings. He was put on edge immediately. There was pity dripping from her after only two words. That couldn’t have meant anything good.
“Danielle,” Rob replied, flat. “That bad, huh?”
“What do you mean?”
“You wanted me to call you and you sound like you’re about to tell me someone died.”
“I should work on my tone, then,” she replied. She was taking her publicist tone now, but rer hesistation only further confirmed his fears. “I pulled some strings with Spotify. Me and someone in their distribution department were in the same sorority.”
“Sound like a pretty successful one.”
“I got the track early,” she continued. “I can’t send it to you, I made some pretty aggressive promises, but I can play it for you now, if you’d like.”
This time, it was Rob’s turn to take a beat.
“…do you think I should?” he asked.
“I’ve been wondering that all day,” she said. “I got this before we spoke this morning, actually. But I talked to my Dad about it and he agreed.”
“I’m sorry?”
“My, uh—” the publicist voice dropped again, and Danielle continued: “My parents split when I was very young. They told me they grew apart and adults are complicated, but I’ve pretty much always known they only stayed together as long as they did for me. Anyways — when I was older, I finally got her to tell me the truth.”
Rob’s voice grew small. “What was the truth?”
“She said it was because one day she realized that she was anyways going to be second. Before they had ever met, Dad had loved a woman that had left him. He hadn’t seen her in decades, he was always loyal to her and loved her as much as he could… but he still held space for her. Somewhere. Despite it all.”
Rob couldn’t say anything anymore.
“Anyways, of course it’s a bit personal for me. And I’m sure this is for you. We’ve all moved on, my parents are great friends and I love them both. I don’t know what’s gone on between you and Mae but I don’t think you deserve to hear it for the first time with millions of other people.”
Tears had already welled up in Robs eyes. “Play it.”
“Sure.”
After a moment, a soft, gentle piano filled the air. Nothing else. And atop, she sang something beautiful, quiet. and devastating:
You held me like a promise
you forgot to keep.
I used to listen to you breathing,
when you were talking in your sleep.
To a ghost.
In a quiet room.
Just a quiet room.
Mae had tried her best to balance the truth with anonymity, but anyone with eyes could see that it was Rob she sang about.
And as he listened, the dam finally broke.
He pressed the heels of his hands hard into his eyes, but it couldn’t stop the tears. He shuttered and shook in quiet grief, his tears falling freely into his lap. He rocked, gently, but it was no comfort.
He couldn’t hide it from himself anymore. She was right.
J never left his heart. She never could. Mae could only ever take up as much space in him as he’d allow, and he’d never allow it all. And he loved her, and he married her, and he had a beautiful daughter with her, but he was hers but she was never fully his.
And now one day, Elle would know. And in a few days, everyone else would, too. There would be no running from this. Not now, not ever.
“Rob?” Danielle had asked. The song had ended a few minutes ago, but his phone stayed muted. He had no words to speak.
“I know you’re muted, you don’t have to say anything. Just… take care of yourself. Call me tomorrow.”
She hesitated a long moment. “There’s an after, after this. Remember that. Goodnight.”
The line disconnected.
And Rob, stripped bare, wept.