ADamnFiddle

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

@Unoedipal

ok kid *tips fedora*

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

@kusanagifire

Pretty sure that @Unoedipal needed to post for our scene, which he probably got confused the conversation i had with @KoLas a contesting situation, mostly me just not caring too much. tbh I don't really care either way whether she actually reached the Copenhagen before my group. As long as it is plausible or w.e.

So I wait for that.

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

@Unoedipal

ur mum doesn't have circuits. #rekt

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

<Snipped quote by Lonewolf685>

Ohh!? She's quite welcome at anytime. It's not like I wouldn't enjoy some yuri being randomly tossed into this, 'cause obviously all girls on Typemoon aren't lesbians in the closet.

But then again, what am I rambling about... just forget that I said anything.

@KoL

Something about everyone being gay, just varying in degrees or something.

<Snipped quote by Lonewolf685>

Who in their sane mind wouldn't fear the Almighty when His representative on Earth is fuckin' Kotomine Kirei? I mean, would you commit a sacrilege in that man's presence?

@KoL

Yes.

<Snipped quote by KoL>

Heretics aren't allowed.

@Unoedipal

E X T E R M I N A T U S

<Snipped quote by ADamnFiddle>

This is pretty much it, honestly. The issue is that I don't plan on setting a precedent of people doing asspulls at the drop of a hat which is largely fueled by OOC knowledge. What you know OOC shouldn't mean that your character figures things out super-easily because you know them. If I allowed that, then it's a slippery slope that I have no intention of walking down.

It's not a balancing thing, since it's hardly like knowing he's Rider helps you, but the issue is moreso that this post wouldn't have been made if I had made Servant CSs secret.

If you legitimately want to argue contrary to that, and say that without knowing anything about him save his appearance, you would have made that post exactly the same, then I really don't know what to say.

@Unoedipal

Honestly I have the same issue as displayed here. You cant really discern someones status as a rider based on their armor alone. They could simply be a saber that could also be summoned as a rider or perhaps someone who could be summoned as a rider that has gone mad during their life. Or an assassin that tells people they are an assassin but are probably not very effective. OLr a guy who shot down all the heads of a beast at the same time. Or a guy riding his suncup. Man, you never know.

Something about not judging a book by their cover and all that glitters is not gold.

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

<Snipped quote by Lonewolf685>

I'd say those are pretty important outliers. For the most part, Servant classes (at least ones not meant to be vague for plot reasons) are the Class they most resemble. It's a leap in logic that carries plenty of risk, but it's still pretty safe when you're going for an obvious solution. Like, say, assuming that the chivalrous knight in cavalry armor is a chivalrous and knightly Rider.

@Scrapula

I mean again, personally I don't really care. I just feel that to be able to discern those sorts of traits from simple glance seems a bit odd is all~. Tbh the end result should not matter all the same.

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

Plus a class isn't as secret as the name; the class would be obvious the moment they do battle.

@Hantu Kongkek

yeah, but at the same time it should not matter if you know their identity or not. However, at the same time you shouldn't be able to discern these traits at simple observation. You could just ask if you really wanted to though. It just seems a bit meta game-y to me tbh.

<Snipped quote by Hantu Kongkek>

Because Sasaki couldn't pass of as Saber. EMIYA was clearly an Archer when he pulled out twin swords. Medusa is obviously not an Assassin.

@Lonewolf685

This is my take on it mostly.

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

@KoL

"It was just a prank, bro." -Iskander, 4th Grail War.

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

<Snipped quote by Hantu Kongkek>

A big knight guy could also use a spear. Or a craziness that's deactivated. Or magecraft. Or a sword. Basically he could theoretically be anyone besides Assassin. A sword actually makes a lot of sense, since he has a sword.

I also don't get why "big knight guy" makes you think "one of those classes that's not called a Knight Class".

Basically there's zero reason to assume he's Rider and you're only doing that because you know he's Rider OOC.

Don't metagame. It's bad.

@Unoedipal

Yeah this is pretty much my take on this. Discernment of identity might hold a small amount of benefit, but only if the necessary steps and prerequisites are accomplished prior to identifying the other. A crazy person swinging rock-sword at you while snarling might be Berserker, but random knight guy 401243 might be a bit harder to properly identify class. Especially if he doesn't currently have any mounts active.

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

@Unoedipal

Umm, personally I think that the Copenhagen should not be within a notable distance when taken into consideration calling for a dispatch taxi and morning traffic and the like, in terms of time spent taken to get there from walking to taxi-ing but at the same time I don't truly believe the ends will matter too much as to if their Magus had moments to prepare. @Turboshitter, what do you think?

Fate/Stagnant Apotheosis

<Snipped quote by ADamnFiddle>

You'd need like, an active triple-modifier and a Game Boy Advance to accomplish that.

You know the one.

@Unoedipal

Boogie-oogie-oogie til you just can't boogie no more [literally]