First off, isn't Mount Hakobe firkin huge? I mean seriously, look:You seem very defensive... I'm sorry if I caused problems or offended... Even if it's huge the dragons are not little... They should probably know each other. Also... It's not just about the magic or first gen or whatever... It's also about the set up. We're like a hundred years in the future. The setting of the RP made it so there weren't anymore dragons. I'm pretty sure Caits told me that. I forget who but it was somewhere pages back. So, I had to come up with a reason for a dragon to actually be alive (please see tale of azuron in my CS if you're wondering). Which i did. This story could pretty easily be altered so that's not a problem with me. Personally, I don't think I have a problem with another Dragon Slayer. I could even help work her dragon into my dragon's history.It's pretty big here. We don't even see the bottom half here I would say. If the mountain is as big as I think, it would not surprise me if two dragons lived on opposite sides. Even if the dragons were to know of each other, it doesn't mean they spoke to each other. Not only that, while Ice and Water are similar elements, there is enough difference to consider them as different magic. Juvia and Gray's fight could be seen as an example of this. I can't help on the Acnologia front, but if one first-gen dragon-slayer got through, I don't see how another one can't either.
It was already ruled that Ice and Water are two distinct magics, right? I think that part's fine, myself. Though, I guess that wasn't made the issue, here.I personally don't see that as an issue either, but being that they are similar, if it is a problem for the Gms I could probably switch my magic type to something different. I would not mind. I don't think the similarity in magic should be a disqualifying point. I like the water and had ideas for it, but I could probably think up something different.