Some Puella Magi in this universe have the power to summon their Witches in a manner similar to the Stands in JoJo's Bizarre Adventure. As duos of Magi and Witch, they fight the Nightmares to keep their Soul Gems fueled. While this is more based on character interaction, there is something of a plot.

The girls present here know they're part of something. They know it, but they don't know what it is they're a part of. They also know there's something else happening, too; something horrible. Only problem is, they have no idea what it is. "What are we a part of? What's this terrible thing that's happening?"

Largely based on character interaction, but it has some direction plot-wise.

Well, the universe has been re-written again. Thanks a lot for that, Homura. Of course, there were some Mahou Shoujo who were still able to summon up their Witch form; part of the Law of Cycle in their own right, and in their own respects equally not part of said entity. With the universe having been reset, there are still Mahou Shoujo like this wandering the world.

This RP will be centering in on a group of such girls. Incubators and Mahou Shoujo may still exist, but even though it's a Witch that writes the laws of the universe now, Witches are generally a thing of the past. Make a contract, and you're assigned to kill Nightmares in exchange for any one given miracle. The abnormalities are the ones who became Witches and died off before the first re-writing of the universe at Madoka's hands. The exact cause is uncertain, but these particular girls (we'll call them "Witch Girls" for lack of a better term) were people who had contracts, became a Witch, and were destroyed before the universe was ever reset. As a bizarre consequence, they're able to summon their Witch as something of a fighting partner.

In this new universe, where Witches technically aren't even supposed to exist anymore, they're an even greater abnormality. Homura stole part of the Law of Cycle and has altered the memories of the remaining pieces (the Witch Girls) to that they no longer recall just what they are in the end. Yes, they're still Mahou Shoujo, and they're certainly unique. But with the memories of the Law of Cycle erased, all that remains is a feeling of once having been part of something much bigger.

"What were we a part of? And what's this feeling that something terrible's happening?"

Largely based on character interaction, but it has some direction plot-wise.