Avatar of TheUnknowable

Status

Recent Statuses

10 yrs ago
Dang it. I can't get Pokemon: GO to work on my cell phone. WHY???
3 likes
10 yrs ago
Where are all of the Xmen games? Deadpool just came out on video and Xmen Apocalypse is about to come out. I was expecting more hype.
1 like

Bio

User has no bio, yet

Most Recent Posts

<Snipped quote by TheUnknowable>

Anti-Heroes are Heroes who lack heroic traits, or do less than heroic deeds for a greater good. The difference is that an Anti-Hero will actually admit that what he does is wrong, and will often actively wish there was a better way. Case and point, Batman. Yes he works outside the law, naturally. But Bruce is constantly lamenting that he even has to do what he does in the first place, that he would like nothing more than for Gotham to clean up its act so he doesn't have to keep wearing the cowl.

And George Washington isn't even remotely similar to Anarchy. Yes, the Colonists overthrew the British rule. But they established an actual legitimate government in its place. What Anarchy is doing is not even close to the same. He overthrew the government and then proceeded to replace it with absolutely nothing. He even took it a step further and abolished all Police and presumably Military. Did he even stop to think about the economic repercussions of his actions? The guy literally fired every single police officer and possibly every single soldier in service. That is hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people that are suddenly out of work and now looking for a new job. The economy is so fucked in that scenario. And I seriously doubt Anarchy can simply hire them all for his security company, no way. Not even Bruce Wayne is that rich. And what about Lexcorp? Since Luthor's gone his company is likely down the toilet, which means all his employees are now also without a job. There's a very high probability that Metropolis is slowly devolving into becoming another Gotham because of this.


1) You are assuming that a government is inherently good, despite the fact that a government only functions through theft and violence.
But this is getting too much into politics, which could ruin the RP.

2) If you shut down a crime ring, do you lament the loss of jobs it's employees suffered? No. They find other jobs if they weren't arrested. In this scenario, there are huge numbers of new businesses being created, and anyone can start their own and offer goods or services if they wish. Sure, it won't be fixed instantly, and things will likely go down hill for a while (creating a demand for experienced police and military) but it will stabilize once enough new jobs exist.

3) Luthor's still around. He's leading Lexcorp. If I indicated otherwise somewhere, I'll fix it.
@RumikoOharaWould she turn down money if they offered to pay her for helping them, or at least giving them priority over missing pets, shop lifters, and purse snatchers?
@DoubleHaving a noble goal but doing evil things to achieve it is an anti-hero, by your own definition.

Was George Washington an anti-villain? He overthrew a government in his country for the sake of Freedom.
@Double He actually has a good reason to not pursue him for that murder, and is having John Stewart investigate him for multiple other crimes, including other murders.

The reason is a secret that will be revealed during the RP though.
@RumikoOharaNot a government. A security company in an anarchist society.

He doesn't collect tax, make laws, or enforce his views on others via police.

He gets paid by customers to rid them of criminals that are hurting them, their property, or their customers/customer's property. Only if they attempt harm, cause harm, or plan to harm will he arrest them, then sends them through a private court system in which he proves that what he Phoenix did was necessary to protect people.

Usually those criminals are super villains, as his fees are too high for run of the meal shoplifters. Others can handle them.
@DoubleI would say that by that definition Batman is an anti-hero. He doesn't always do things "by the book".

Anarchy's goal was to free people from theft, coercion, assault, slavery, murder, etc. especially when it was done by an organized group.

That is what the government was, at least in his view, which is why he began targeting government installations and exposing their crimes. When he was attacked by their soldiers, the Justice League, he fought back by joining with criminals and, in the process, was able to lessen the severity of their crimes. Sure, joining them wasn't right, but if he didn't he would be in Belle Reve, so he fought back.

His goal was to free people and save them from criminals, that just happened to include the government. He still protects people, only now it's as private security. He did dark things, helping criminals with minor crimes and counter-attacking the "heroes", but he did it to work towards his goal, and only as much as was needed to complete it.
@RumikoOharaIn fact, now that I think about it, she might have done work for Phoenix in the past or be an employee. That ability would be very useful in tracking criminals.
@RumikoOharaYou could also probably read the Krytonite blade or the buried ashes. We just need to get the blade from Luthor or dig up the urn.
@mattmanganonEven when it shows you that the person offered him a chance to retreat or call a truce, showed the man he was armed and would defend himself, and the man still tried to attack him?
@mattmanganontechnically, it was Luthor that killed him. anarchy was just going to imprison him sans powers. So, if he's coming to collect Anarchy's head, Anarchy will show him body cam footage of the real target, and pay him a bonus for his arrest and extradition to another world.
© 2007-2026
BBCode Cheatsheet