Well, while they are all like "He's precious" Ice would more over be like, "Better make sure this kid doesn't wind up dead" he'd actually probably feel the same way about Kara, even if he does learn about her age.
Mary lives right across from Cookie.. that's not gonna cause issues, right?
These are the gifts and their recipients, as well as my logic behind it. Felix Garfield: Athletic Support cuff
Very helpful for free-running.
Tekhartha Mondatta: Prayer beads
Commonly used for buddhist prayers. In particular, these have Buddhist sayings inscribed in them.
Kara O'Hara: Adventures in Cooking
She's the only chef, so a cookbook would make a perfect gift
Caora "Cookie" Uan Artzain: Touch-Touch Book Farm
A common method of helping people with psychosis coming back to reality is "stimming". Stimming allows the patient to feel a comfortable and predictable stimuli, which is especially useful in situations where the other available stimuli is unpredictable. The method reduces stress and keeps the patient happy.
That, and it's bright with fluffy animals. what's not to like?
Shaun Ellen: Spider's Sting
"Web" designer? "Spider" Sting? Monokuma gave it away in his introduction.
Aleccia Marvic: Braille Othello board
A braille board game, suitable for a blind game master.
Davis Gallo: Glorious Golden Gladius
The gladius is a symbol of Rome, one of the greatest Empires in history. Such a symbol would be perfect for a man whose talent is "Conquest"
Cyrus Brandon: Men's make-up mirror
A politician must always look their best.
Rika Roux: Jar of dragon fire
Rika is a pyromaniac who likes spicy things. Dragon Fire will appeal to that love of spice
Mason Brady: Play Place Portable
The game on it is a casual coffee game. A good choice for the laid back barista
Calvin Parker Ibbott: Orichalcum Ingot
You can't make weapons without ingots
Krista Noelle Muller: Violin care package
Krista is the only one who plays violin.
Quill Kennedy: Trinity of Laughs
A sitcom about fashion models? Sounds like something Quill will relate to.
Shona Moffett: Knight's Squire Ale
Verily, I doth proclaim that some Olde Timey Mead wouldst make the p'rfect gift for thon olde timey Knight.
Daimyon Londe: Untethered
The prose-poetry mix sounds like something that would catch the resident poet's attention.
Mary Hanson: Selfie Stick
Mary said it herself "How will I survive without my selfies"? She didn't say anything about suffocating my poor Caora, but she did that anyway...
Ice Matthews: Jar of Red Faeries
Red sweets " often given to blood donors after they give blood". Something Ice would use regularly, no?