AngelTheWolf
AThousandCursesRoleplaying like this is co-writing. You're writing a story together with other people. This type of Roleplay is not like a game. It's not D&D. It's not a RPG. It's literally like writing an actual book, but with a ton of people. You're writing something with a group of people. So I can say it's a roleplay, because it still is, but it's not a table-top roleplay. Roleplay isn't like that when written out online like this. It's literal, a story that you're writing together.
There are some differences. Also, I think you are being just a smidge harsh.
Also, if you really want this to be a story, you need history so you don't have 19-24 moon old cats roaming around with literally no experiences to write about. If they were all kits, this would work, the no history thing, but if you are going to make them so old you kind of have to give each of them individual experiences otherwise it becomes kinda bland.
Don't mean to push, do what you like, but that's where I'm at.