I had a few recent ideas but i figured i could just list them and see which are more appealing for a group rp:
1.) a fantasy school that trains fantasy heroes or healers, and sends them out onto the battlefield upon their graduation in order to serve their king, who is frail and unable to defend himself and his kingdom. This school is his and their homelands only chance to ensure the survival of the realm of fantasy as they knew it.
2.) a romantic tale of a girl/boy who falls in love with a classmate/teacher, at a university, unaware they are actually a creature of fantasy sent there to spy on the current populace.
3.) a festival/ceremony where a guy/girl is offered up to a dark fantasy-type creature, taking place in a more modern setting, in order to keep their city from being destroyed. Takes place every red moon. But, there is a twist that will really change everything, and keep things from going as the leader of the city intended.
4.) A beach-side town surrounded in a mystery of fantasy. The people are forbidden to go near the water, mainly due to a legend believed to be true. Since their ancestors first founded the town, there were sightings of merpeople and other fantasy ocean creatures popping up out of the water and even living on/along the beach at times, always for a few days/nights and always starting around a full moon. However, a group of people choose to ignore the warning and the words forbidding them from going there, and they let curiosity get the better of them, and they head towards the water during a full moon.
5.) a boarding house where most of the residents are fantasy creatures. A story of a day to day life, and some struggles, and perhaps romance if desired. A new resident moves in, a human, and everything changes around the boarding house. Good or bad? Time will tell.
6.) A culinary school where fantasy creatures learn to cook human food, and where humans learn to cook fantasy dishes. The students must learn to help each other in order to graduate from the school.
7.) A fantasy story where a girl is sucked in through a mysterious mirrored wall into a fantasy world. There, she finds out her mother was the queen of a kingdom there and that she is their princess. Confused, she is told that her mother left with her when she was just a baby, into the human world, in order to keep her safe until her 18th birthday, when she would pick a suitor to marry and inherit the throne from her mother. This is the journey of a girl from a modern city thrust into the realm of fantasy.
8.) A tale of fantasy, and adventure, where a crystal rose is shattered and it is up to a team of six to find a way to restore it, lest their modern city of magic loose all magic forever.